Did Carolyn Bessette Really Resist JFK Jr.'s Proposal? The True Story Behind Their Engagement
Did Carolyn Bessette Really Resist JFK Jr.'s Proposal? The True Story Behind Their Engagement
Jordana ComiterSat, February 28, 2026 at 12:45 PM UTC
0
John F. Kennedy Jr. and Carolyn Bessette during the annual White House Correspondents dinner on May 1, 1999, in Washington, D.C. ; Sarah Pidgeon and Paul Anthony Kelly in 'Love Story: John F. Kennedy Jr. & Carolyn Bessette'Credit: Tyler Mallory/Getty ; FX -
Episode 5 of Love Story: JFK Jr. and Carolyn Bessette includes the political heir's proposal to the Calvin Klein associate
The on-screen proposal had both similarities and differences to their real-life engagement
In real life, JFK Jr. popped the question in 1995 on Martha's Vineyard
John F. Kennedy Jr.'s proposal to Carolyn Bessette was anything but ordinary.
The political heir and the Calvin Klein associate's engagement played out on-screen in episode 5 of Love Story: JFK Jr. and Carolyn Bessette, titled "Battery Park." In the limited series, JFK Jr. popped the question following a weekend at the Kennedy Compound in Hyannis Port, Mass. But, Bessette said no, telling him they still have to talk about how their lives will "fit together."
Bessette's hesitation led to the couple getting into an infamous public fight in a New York City park on-screen — which did happen in real life, but not because of the engagement. As history shows, she eventually said yes to JFK Jr.'s proposal and the pair tied the knot on Sept. 21, 1996.
Here's everything to know about JFK Jr.'s real-life proposal to Carolyn Bessette.
JFK Jr. proposed on Martha's Vineyard in 1995
John F. Kennedy Jr. and Carolyn Bessette on May 23, 1999.Credit: Justin Ide/Newsmakers via Getty
JFK Jr. proposed to Bessette on Martha's Vineyard after the Fourth of July weekend in 1995.
As JFK Jr.'s former assistant RoseMarie Terenzio wrote in her 2024 book JFK Jr.: An Intimate Oral Biography — co-written by PEOPLE editor-at-large Liz McNeil — he popped the question while taking Bessette out on a boat.
Terenzio recalled Bessette telling her, "He said, 'When you go fishing, it's always better with a partner. Will you be my partner?' "
He gave Bessette two rings — but it wasn't his mother's toi et moi
JFK Jr. and his wife Carolyn Bessette attend the "Brite Nite Whitney" Fundraising Gala on March 9, 1999Credit: Arnaldo Magnani/Liaison
In the series, JFK Jr. proposes to Bessette with his late mother Jackie Kennedy's ring. But in real life, Bessette's engagement ring was instead inspired by Jackie's "swimming ring."
According to McNeil and Terenzio's book, JFK Jr. gave Bessette two rings, including his mother's "swimming ring," which Jackie wore when she didn't wear her real wedding sparkler.
JFK Jr. had asked the late diamond magnate Maurice Tempelsman to create a version of the emerald-and-sapphire "swimming ring." Bessette's ring was in the same style, but with diamonds and sapphires around a band, per the book.
Advertisement
Bessette resisted the proposal for about three weeks
JFK Jr. and Carolyn Bessette.Credit: Richard Corkery/NY Daily News Archive via Getty
As seen in the show, Bessette did resist JFK Jr.'s proposal in real life. According to Elizabeth Beller's 2024 book Once Upon a Time: The Captivating Life of Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy, Bessette responded to his question by saying, "I’ll think about it."
In June 2017, a close friend of JFK Jr.'s told PEOPLE that Bessette held the proposal off for "about three weeks," which made him "all the more intent on marrying her." But, she did eventually say yes.
The couple kept their engagement secret and JFK Jr. denied it when it began spreading in the media
JFK Jr. and Carolyn Bessette on Nov. 5, 1997Credit: Ron Galella Collection via Getty
After JFK Jr. and Bessette got engaged, the couple kept it a secret, as their relationship wasn't officially on the media's radar yet, per McNeil and Terenzio's book. Terenzio wrote that the Calvin Klein associate was trying to avoid being "under a microscope" once the news got out.
However, the New York Post published an enlarged photo of Bessette's hand with the engagement ring ahead of Labor Day weekend. As the speculation began spreading in the press, JFK Jr. initially thought it was best to ignore it.
However, with the George magazine press conference happening the following weekend, he and his business partner were concerned that the conversations around the potential engagement would overshadow their launch of the publication. So, they decided to issue a denial statement which Terenzio read at the press conference.
"Once again, John Kennedy seems to be bearing the brunt of a slow news day," she said, per her and McNeil's book. "The stories circulating regarding an engagement are untrue. He is not engaged."
JFK Jr.'s friend Sasha Chermayeff wrote in McNeil and Terenzio's book that the public denial was the first sign for Bessette that "this is what life with him is going to be about."
"It's going to be about whatever looks good for him and his world, and I just have whatever role I'm given," Chermayeff added.
Although Bessette was hurt by JFK Jr.'s public denial of the engagement, the couple moved forward and got married in September 1996 in a private ceremony in Georgia.
For more on the lives of John F. Kennedy Jr and Carolyn Bessette Kennedy, pick up PEOPLE's special edition, available now on newsstands and here.
on People
Source: “AOL Entertainment”
